Ask Question
Sign Guest book

 
About Lymphoma
| Advocacy & Art | CAM & Life Style | Clinical trials | Doctors & Centers  | Guidelines  at  Diagnosis | How  to   Help  | Research | Side Effects  | Support | Symptoms  | Tests | Treatments


WebCasts

Comparing Protocols

  

Treatment Overview > Comparing protocols

Last update: 11/19/2003

The purpose of the Treatment Pros and Cons table is to provide a concise overview of treatment options for NHL patients.   This is a work in progress.  

Also see Emerging Treatments

TREATMENT

TYPE | PROS | CONS

CONTACT

Allo Mini Transplant - Patients are given immune suppressing chemotherapy and then received a blood stem cell transplant from a matched family donor. Patients also received treatment to prevent graft-versus-host (GVH) disease or a graft-incompatibility reaction. Experimental/promising: Lower toxicity than BMT, relies on a graft versus tumor effect of the transplant.

Main issues is rate of donor engraftment (chimerism), the necessity and timing for infusion of donor lymphocytes after transplant, and tumor bulk.  Whether this is resulting in lower rates of later complications (e.g. chronic GVHD) or higher response rates or even cures are unknown.

Memorial Sloan Kettering NYC, MD Anderson Cancer Center Houston,

Michael R. Bishop, MD
National Cancer Institute
Bldg. 10, Room 12N226
Bethesda, MD 20892
Phone: 301-435-2764 FAX: 301-480-4354
E-mail: mbishop@mail.nih.gov

anti-bcl-2 Genesense (formerly known as G3139).  An antisense therapy that inhibits expression of  the bcl-2 protein, which prevents cell death and is over expressed in many lymphomas Experimental/promising: Low toxicity, does not effect other protocols.   Use with other agents, such as Rituxan, looks especially promising! May work best in combination with other  therapies. Tara Spiess
Associate Director of Operations
Corporate Communications
Two Oak Way
Berkeley Heights, New Jersey 07922
(973) 847-5905
spiess@genta.com
Antiangiogenesis Thalidomide, squalamine, SU5416, decoppering, decoppering, endo/angiostatins, numerous other agents.  Prevents formation of blood vessels that support tumor growth. Experimental/promising: Generally low toxicity. May enhance other therapies. Few studies for NHL, but Thalidomide and SU5416 studies will start soon according to NCI.   Cox-2 inhibitors (such as NSAIDS) may also have antiangiogenesis properties.

New.  Little data for efficacy yet.

National Cancer Institute
Antineoplastons naturally occurring peptides or chains of amino acids and organic acids combined with carboxylic acids system. Usually administered with 24 hour infusion pump. Experimental/no long-term toxicity: Some patients report benefit, but published results are not available.

Quality of life: Not without side effects, which may include stomach gas, slight rashes, chills, fever, change in blood pressure, and unpleasant body odor during treatment.   The protocol dramatically impacts quality of life and is very expensive.

Cost:
Average treatment time ranges from 4-12 months, and annual costs range from $36,000-$60,000 depending on the type of treatment, number of consultations, and surgical procedures necessary for insertion of catheterization devices for treatment delivery. The oral treatment is less expensive.
Cost:
Average treatment time ranges from 4-12 months, and annual costs range from $36,000-$60,000 depending on the type of treatment, number of consultations, and surgical procedures necessary for insertion of catheterization devices for treatment delivery. The oral treatment is less expensive.
Cost:
Average treatment time ranges from 4-12 months, and annual costs range from $36,000-$60,000 depending on the type of treatment, number of consultations, and surgical procedures necessary for insertion of catheterization devices for treatment delivery. The oral treatment is less expensive.
  

My note: I do not recommend this treatment because the investigator has not yet published results for NHL.  I would like to see this, and all interesting agents, combined with mainstream agents to identify low toxic combination treatments.  This is a lay opinion based on direct experience with the treatment and personal contact with many patients who have tried it.
Arsenic trioxide (Trisenox) Therapeutic concentrations of As2O3 (1-2 microM) had dual effects on malignant lymphocytes: 1) inhibition of growth through adenosine triphosphate (ATP) depletion and prolongation of cell cycle time and 2) induction of apoptosis. Promising/Approved/No myelosuppression: FDA approved for the treatment of APL (a form of leukemia) in which it has been shown to induce clinical remission with low toxicity and no myelosuppression. It is not blocked by drug resistance so previous chemotherapy will not reduce its efficacy and it can be used in combination with other therapies.

Because Trisenox does not cause significant myelosuppression, it may prove beneficial as a pretreatment for vaccines and other immunotherapies.

At Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, patients with relapsed or refractory intermediate- or high-grade NHL are being treated with arsenic
trioxide, 0.25 mg/kg/day, 5 days a week for 5 weeks.

In a trial at Mount Sinai Hospital (New York, NY), patients with relapsed or refractory low-grade NHL or CLL are eligible for treatment with arsenic trioxide.  Trial site

Bexxar (Tositumomab and iodine I 131 Tositumomab) -targets CD20 antigen on b-cells with radiolabeled isotope.

Experimental/promising: Medium/low toxicity. High reported remission rate published for follicular type positive for CD20. Possibility of durable remission. Combined with CVP in some trials

 See table comparing it to Zevalin

Recently approved. 

Best use still under investigation

Phone: (415) 842-7300, or Sylvia Wheeler (415) 842-7306 Fax: (415) 842-7303

Columbia-Presbyterian Medical Center NYC  212-746-6735

BMT- (Stem Cell transplant) high dose chemotherapy/ bexxar to kill all immune cells, followed by bone marrow implantation from previously harvested cells or donor cells.

Experimental/promising: Need information about remission/cure rate.

High toxicity; can be fatal. May improve disease-free remissions.

Center srch: http://www2.bmtinfonet.org/centers/index.cfm

888-597-7674

Chemotherapy-usually Cisplatin, CHOP, Fludarabine (FND), CVP, EPOCH, , ICE, PEPC, PROMACE.   Many combination.  Also used with Rituxan and other new drugs.

Conventional: Good first-line remission rates. Many combinations (such as Fludarabine) available with various toxicity. Can be used with Rituxan to improve effect; may be used with other therapies (Rituxan?) to reduce dose/toxicity. ICE is a new combination therapy that is getting very good results.

High Toxicity. Diminishing benefits with retreatment. May preclude use of future immunotherapies, such as  idiotype vaccines. Can cause secondary cancers.  Fludarabine, for example, can severely diminish immune function in the bone marrow making it difficult to mobilize stem cells.

Consult NHL expert (LRFA)
Chemotherapy, low daily oral dose - PEP-C (Prednisone, cyclophosphamide, etoposide, procarbazine)
Novel use of conventional: Good results and low toxicity.  Daily oral dose maintains continuous serum drug levels sufficient to override at least one drug resistance mechanism.   Therapy may also be antiangiogenic. Excellent response rates for follicular, mantle cell See toxicity for chemotherapy.  However, this well-tolerated treatment may be less toxic particularly if  not used for extended periods of time. Columbia-Presbyterian Medical Center NYC  212-746-6735

Protocol details

HSP vaccine- (Oncophage) consists of autologous heat shock protein-peptide complexes derived from the patient's own tumor Experimental/promising: No data for NHL, but in theory it should work on all cancers. 

Current trial at MDACC requires resectible 4x4 cm node(s), prior treatment no longer required,   no bulky or fast growing disease. Protocol may change to allow pretreatment with Rituxan for untreated patients.

MDACC, Dr. Anas Younes
Antigenics
 
Demo

Idiotype vaccine - tumor-derived vaccine used to prevent recurrence. Many variations under study.

Experimental/promising: Used after initial treatment has produced sustained remission in small, but significant, study

Not available now for patients who have been previously treated. Requires prior chemotherapy or Rituxan

Also see Vaccine

Interferon alpha-a protein created naturally by leucocytes (immune cells) that has shown efficacy against lymphoma in major European studies. Other US studies have not confirmed benefit, however. Experimental/promising: Has shown efficacy in some, but not all published studies.

Cons: May be difficult to tolerate treatment.  Requires frequent injections.  Different types are available, such as Roferon (interferon alpha 2A) A new form, Pegylated interferon, which allows once weekly injections instead of daily injections might prove useful.

May be most useful in combination with other immunotherapies, such as Rituxan.  Pegylated version might improve dosing and reduce side effects.

Can be prescribe by your oncologist.

Also see Biologics

Lym-1 antibody, radiolabeled with Yttrium-90 (Y-90) Experimental/promising: Treatment of all grades of non-Hodgkin’s lymphomas. Result promising for patients who have failed other therapies See eligibility See contact

Also see Radioimmunotherapies

LymphoCideTM Y-90:Yttrium-90-labeled humanized antibody targeting CD22 receptors in B-cell lymphomas

Experimental/promising: Treatment of indolent and aggressive non-Hodgkin’s lymphomas. Result promising for patients who have failed other therapies

Requires CD22 positive tumors. May be hard to get into trials.

Phase I/II trial using antibody labeled with yttrium-90 is being conducted at The Garden State Cancer Center in NJ and in Europe.

LymphoCide (epratuzumab) Naked humanized antibody targeting CD22 receptors in B-cell lymphomas

Experimental/promising: Treatment of indolent non-Hodgkin’s lymphomas. Result promising for patients who have failed other therapies. Small phase II study indicates it may enhance magnitude of response (more CRs) to Rituxan.

Requires CD22 positive tumors. 

Phase I/II trial using unlabeled (non-isotopic) antibody | Rituxan + LL-2 for patients with no prior Rituxan.
Columbia-Presbyterian Medical Center NYC
  212-746-6735

NCI Dr. Robert Kreitman 301-402-5633

ASCO

PS-341 VELCADE™ (bortezomib)
thought to interfere with the function of an important cellular protein complex, and provokes cells to program their own destruction. 
"The results from this study (phase I) are exciting because PS-341 was able to benefit several patients who were not helped by standard chemotherapy," Orlowski said. PS-341 seemed particularly active in two diseases: multiple myeloma and non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. Also called LDP-341 Millenium Pharmaceuticals
mlnm.com

Also see Emerging Treatments

 

Radiotherapy - localized, or Central Lymphatic Radiation (CLI) is a protocol (92-102)

Conventional: Can cure or achieve long term remission in localized lymphomas in some cases.

For non-contiguous stage II and stage III indolent lymphoma, central lymphatic irradiation has been proposed but is not usually recommended as a form of treatment.16,17"

Toxicity-can cause secondary cancers.

MDA in a study comparing it to Alternating Triple Therapy (ATT) to see which has better results for indolent. So far, results have been essentially similar, so the study keeps going. They think they may be getting as much as a 60% "cure" rate which I think they define as a ten year remission.

USC Dept of Radiation Oncology
e-mail: thsu@hsc.usc.edu

Also see Radiotherapy

Rituxan - monoclonal antibody that binds to CD20 positive lymphoma cells and induces cell lysis (death)

Approved Immunotherapy: Low toxicity in most pts, may not effect other protocols, enhances CHOP, may be used more than once. Best results for follicular NHL.

Rituxan can be used repeatedly. Remarkably, some of these subsequent remissions have latest longer than the first remission.

IDEC- (619) 550-8500

See Rituxan for details

Thalidomide - angiogenesis and immune enhancing

New versions under investigation.

Experimental/unproven: Moderate toxicity. My Note: May be a good to try during watch & wait. Can be prescribed now, although not approved for NHL.

Unproven. May cause neuropathy if used over a long period of time. Requires special permission (see STEPS).

To register in STEPS, please call 1-888-4-235436

Web info from Celgene

Also see Emerging Treatments

Vecade -  See Thought to interfere with the function of an important cellular protein complex, and provokes cells to program their own destruction. "The results from this study (phase I) are exciting because PS-341 was able to benefit several patients who were not helped by standard chemotherapy," Orlowski said. PS-341 seemed particularly active in two diseases: multiple myeloma and non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. Also called LDP-341    

Zevalin-monoclonal antibody that targets the CD20 antigen and is stably linked to the radioisotope 90Yttrium.

Recently approved: Medium/low toxicity. High reported remission rate published for follicular type positive for CD20. Possibility of durable remission.

Unknown long-term toxicity. Recently approved
(See table comparing it to Bexxar)

IDEC- (619) 550-8500

Also see Radioimmunotherapies

 
Disclaimer:  The information presented on Lymphomation.org is not intended to be a substitute for 
professional medical advice or to replace your relationship with a physician.
For all medical concerns,  you should always consult your doctor. 
Patients Against Lymphoma, Copyright © 2004,  All Rights Reserved.